- Hard Case for Palm Tungsten T
- Compatible with Palm Tungsten T/T2
Sure, it's sleek and carries out the design theme of the Tungsten/T itself. It is also beautifully engineered, using a clever mounting which allows the Tungsten/T to slide open while mounted in the case (with the cover open), plus when closed a cutout allows access to the voice memo feature. Another clever addition is the dual SD card holder integrated into the inside cover (although I personally have no need to carry extra cards).
The size is simply excessive. The compact-sized Tungsten/T alone is only 4" tall by 3" wide by 5/8" thick. But in the case, the dimensions grow to 4-3/8" tall by 3-3/8" wide by 7/8" thick. The external hinge causes the width increase, while the 40% increase in thickness is caused by a combination of the SD stick storage and standoffs which give extra clearance from the screen and buttons. If you carry your palm in your purse, briefcase or jacket pocket, the size may not be bothersome, but if you carry it in a pants pocket, the size increase is significant. If you previously owned a Palm V (or Vx)with the minimally-intrusive Palm hard case, you may be disappointed with this one, as am I.
After all, didn't you buy the Tungsten/T largely because of its super-compact size? Then why does Palm think we want to significantly increase its size by using an oversized hard case for it?
Buy PalmOne Tungsten T and T2 Hard Case P10897U Now
The case is fairly well made and will no doubt protect your Palm reasonably well; however, I quickly grew disenchanted with it for several reasons.First, the case does not completely enclose the Palm, a fact that is not evident from the pictures. When closed, the top and left side are still exposed, allowing access to the stylus, memory card, IR port, power button, audio jack and voice memo button. It's very possible, then, for the memory card or stylus to be ejected while the unit is in a purse or backpack, or for the unit to be turned on. While access to the jack and record button could be useful, it's unclear to me why the designers thought that access to the Palm's top was necessary. There's also a thumb cutout in the back panel for some reason, perhaps to aid in removing the Palm from the case. but it is hardly necessary.
Secondly, Palm's marketing material claims that the case allows you 'full access to all Tungsten T handheld features.' That's true only if you don't consider using Graffiti a feature, as you can't expand the Palm -and thus can not enter any data -while it's in the case.
Thirdly, the claimed 'spring loaded hinge and attachment clip to hold your device securely in place' is hardly that. The attachment clips are perhaps 2mm long. Pressing the power button or inserting/removing a memory card requires enough force that you will also unseat the Palm from the case.
There are additional flaws. The expansion card slots are polarized, for some unfathomable reason, so that cards can only be stored so that the card contacts are exposed and the label can't be seen. And the spring loaded hinge doesn't always keep the case completely closed. It sometimes gapes open a few millimeters, allowing any sharp objects that might be in your bag with it the opportunity to get in and scratch the screen. Finally, the packaging also claims that the case has a cushioned lining. You can probably guess that there is none; the case is aluminum over plastic.
Read Best Reviews of PalmOne Tungsten T and T2 Hard Case P10897U Here
I just got this hard aluminum case for my Tungsten T (TT). I absolutely love it. While considering which case to get, I checked out the leather case by Palm, too, but it didn't look nearly as good as this hard case. In fact, I thought the leather case looked poorly made in comparison.Here are some reasons why I like the hard aluminum case:
1. You can see and feel that the case is custom made for the TT. My TT fits nice and snug in the case (which is a wonderful feeling).
2. The springs in the case and two rectangular holes in the back of the TT (take a look) are used to secure the TT in the case. It works fabulously. With a swift, effortless (I'm not exaggerating) move (gently pressing downward and pulling the Palm towards onerself), the TT can be removed from the case. This makes the hard case superior to the leather one, which uses clips on both sides like the cheap plastic cover that comes standard with the TT. The clips just don't feel as secure and tend to loosen after a while. I always feel like I have to be extra careful when dealing with the clips. Not the case with the springs.
3. The hinges that hold the case cover are great. The cover doesn't just flip open and dangle about. Sure, they're plastic, but they're also cleverly made so that you can open the case cover at 120 degrees or 180 degrees. When you close it, one gets a nice click.
4. I don't think the case is made of aluminum, which is actually a plus for me because the material has more give and is softer. The material is definitely more scratch-resistant than real aluminum.
5. My TT feels well-protected. Every part of the TT, except the top and the bit where the earphone jack and voice memo button are, is covered by the case. The fact that the bottom is covered is especially significant. This way, I don't feel like my TT will slide off and/or drop when I use it while standing and holding it more vertically.
I have to agree with some of the other reviews that this case might not be as ideal for lefties. And yes, the case increases the size of your TT, but it doesn't bother me. Honestly, any decent case out there would make your TT bigger. The other common criticism about this case is that one can not pull down and use the grafitti section when the TT's in this case. The solution is simple: PULL UP INSTEAD! In fact, the case is conveniently designed to make pulling up to expose the grafitti section easy.
The case takes a little getting used to, but once you know how to use it, you'll appreciate it.
Want PalmOne Tungsten T and T2 Hard Case P10897U Discount?
I was wondering why I could not find this hard case anywhere that the Tungsten was sold, and I had to order it online.Upon receipt of the case I figured out why: on the internet you can fool people by showing them a picture of an "aluminum" case and it looks aluminum. You can't fool people when the item is right in front of their eyes.
Do not be fooled: this case is made of ... plastic. The hinge is also made of plastic, and every time I open the case it feels like it is about to crack in half.
If you are left-handed, this case will not feel ergonomic in your hand, as the person from Ireland pointed out below.
When the item this case is supposed to protect is more rugged than the case itself, you know you have a problem.
It is a shame that such a well-made, classy item like the Tungsten does not have a decent case to hold it.
Save 62% Off
I rec'd. this case a few days ago, and overall am quite pleased. While I was under the impression that the case was aluminum, actually it appears to be vapor metallized aluminum on plastic (i.e., more plastic than aluminum). It holds the Tungsten very secure in the "closed" mode (i.e., w/ the slider closed rather than extended)and quite secure w/ the Tungsten's slider extended. Other benefits:-2 slots inside the case for extra SD cards
-a cut-a-way on the side of the case for easy access to the voice recorder button
-open top for easy access to power button as well as to slide open (extend) the Tungsten
-it's still small enough to fit into a normal shirt pocket and not be too bulky / obvious
-a cut-out on the back to make extending the Tungsten very easy while still keeping it in its case
-a nice, "Palm" embossing on the front that's not too large / obnoxious
The case could be improved if it had the option of attaching a belt clip, was a bit more sturdy (metal), and was a bit less expensive. ... seems a bit steep for this case.
No comments:
Post a Comment